The spice rub is only a guideline, but the timing and temperature of this meal must be followed "to the letter" for great results. This method is made for meat lovers as it produces a medium-rare to rare meat that melts in your mouth! I think the hands-off method used in this blog scares a number of timid cooks, and that's why you can look like a hero when you boldly cook what others won't. Then, to top it off, it tastes like it came from a Texas Steakhouse! Trust me, this is the easiest thing you have made and it will WOW the crowd. You will forever be remembered for your prime rib.
Ingredients-
Prime rib, bone on- 4 or more pounds (about 1 lb per serving)
Butter 1/4 lb per every 4 lbs of meat
Black pepper
Kosher salt
Powdered garlic
Basil
Rosemary
Thyme
Whatever spices you like
Here is the first step that many cooks don't want to do. You must let the prime rib warm up to room temperature. That scares away any timid cook giving you an edge. You need to let it set out at room temperature for a good 6-7 hours! Bold yes?
I salt and pepper all sides of the meat then wrap it in aluminum foil. Place it on a plate on the counter at room temperature for 6-7 hours. This method will not work if the meat is not at room temperature. Take notice of the prime rib's weight, this is important as the cooking time depends on it. Also, at this time, set the butter out to warm. While you wait, enjoy a few beers but not enough to ruin 50 or 100 dollars worth of meat!
After the meat is warm, preheat the oven to 500 degrees, and make a buttery rub. This is up to you. Use whatever flavors you want as you are not going to ruin this prime rib. I gave you a few ideas here. I might suggest you pick a theme for your guests like- "My Rosemary Garlic Prime Rib." Don't use too many spices as it will often muddle the flavors. What is important is to use lots of salt and pepper in whatever themed rub you use. Honestly, it's the liberal use of salt and pepper that flavor the meat.
After you have mixed the rub, take the foil off your prime rib and pat it dry. Place it ribs down in a roasting pan. Rub all sides with the butter mixture, excluding the underside.
Wait until the oven is at 500 degrees then pop it in the oven. Let the meat cook in the oven for 5 minutes per pound plus 2 minutes. For example- a 6.2 lb prime rib stays at 500 degrees for (6.2x5) +2=33 minutes. After the timer runs out, turn off the heat (leave the prime rib in the oven) and wait at least 2 hours. The heat in your oven will perfectly cook the meat. Do no open your oven at any time or this method will fail miserably. After 2 hours, open your oven and serve! You don't have to let the meat rest as it already has. Also, at this point, the meat can wait in the oven for another 1/2 hour or so to stay warm if need be. That's your prep window for the rest of your meal - 2 to 2 1/2 hours.
If you'd like, and I strongly suggest that you do, you can make an easy dipping sauce. Simply put the pan drippings into a fry pan and add a bit of red wine. Reduce the mix over medium heat. You don't need to add any salt or pepper as the drippings are full of flavor! You can thicken a bit with flour if you like, but you don't have to. It's all up to you! The taste is intense. Serve it in a tiny dish to the side of the meat. I didn't show the sauce, any sides, not even a beer! I wanted you to look at that great Prime Rib!
This prime rib will not disappoint you! Enjoy!